This article contains affiliate links. If you purchase through these links, Football Finance Lab may earn a commission at no additional cost to you.
Heart of Midlothian have played one of the most successful seasons in the club’s history, finishing second and losing the league title to Celtic with a defeat on the final day of the season. This would have been the first Scottish championship that has gone to Aberdeen FC since 1985, not to the two Glasgow giants. Nonetheless, Hearts have had an incredibly strong and historic season. In this article, however, we do not analyze the successes on the pitch, but instead what financial resources the club uses alongside the pitch and how ownership of the club has changed in recent years, as well as the impact of this on sporting results.
History of Ownership Turmoil and Financial Collapse
Hearts, as the club is usually called, was founded in 1874 and supposedly takes its name from the dance hall „The Heart of Midlothian Dancing Club“. It is therefore one of the largest traditional clubs in Scottish football. Hearts experienced the club’s most successful years at the end of the 19th century, where they celebrated two Scottish championships and four cup wins. In total, the club has won 4 Scottish championships and 8 Scottish Cups. In the early 2000s, Scottish football was in a serious financial crisis. As part of a PWC investigation into the debts of Scottish clubs, it became public that Hearts is one of five clubs that are virtually insolvent. To avert bankruptcy, the club planned to cut players’ salaries and sell the stadium. Another way to make money from your stadium is through a cooperative, which we analyzed using Schalke 04 and FC St. Pauli as examples. However, since this was not in the interest of many fans and other shareholders with smaller shares in the club, this opened the door for Vladimir Romanov. In 2004, Romanov bought 19.6% of Hearts from Chris Robinson, who was considered one of the leaders, to prevent the stadium from being sold. By this time, Heart of Midlothian had already sold its Tynecastle stadium, but withdrew from the sale with an integrated clause in 2005. This was then done with the support of the new investor Romanov. After Romanov provided further financial assurances to avert Hearts’ insolvency, Vladimir Romanov was able to acquire further shares in the club. He increased his shares to 29.9%, which ensured that he gained control of the club. Overall, Romanov bought 82% of all shares of Hearts, making him the majority shareholder.
After taking over Romanov, he took the lead, especially in sporting matters, and made a few questionable decisions. Next to the pitch, Romanov promised to reduce the club’s debts, which he failed to do. The debt rose to approximately 42 million euros in 2007. These financial problems continued into the 2008/2009 season, culminating in Hearts’ debt being approximately €14 million higher than equity. This shows the precarious financial situation Hearts continued to face despite Romanov’s takeover. In addition, the club was only able to pay players’ salaries late in the same season. In 2013, the deal came in the form of the insolvency of the Lithuanian bank Unio Bankas, which was more than 50% owned by Vladimir Romanov and from which he derived his assets. The club’s debts amounted to approximately 17 million euros and at that time were largely owed to this bank, which held the 29.9% shares and Hearts’ stadium as collateral. The bank’s insolvency forced it to sell its shares in Hearts and the stadium as insolvency assets. In addition, the club owed a further 11.5 million euros to UBIG, the parent company of Unio Bankas, which also went bankrupt. Romanov’s bankruptcy led to Heart of Midlothian also going bankrupt and therefore receiving a point deduction as a penalty and thus even being relegated to the second division. Fans continued to generate income from day-to-day business through fundraising campaigns and increased season ticket sales until Ann Budge (a Scottish businesswoman) took over the club’s business with Bidco 1874 in 2014. Together with a fan organization, they raised money to liquidate the club and Bidco committed to taking over the club’s business for 5 years until it is handed over to the fan organization. A total of 7.4 million euros was raised from 8,000 participants to liquidate the club and make 75.5% of the club’s shares fan-owned. This great performance by the fans ensured that the club was ultimately able to pay off the remaining debt of 1.2 million euros, buy back the shares in the club for 3 million euros and even generate 3.2 million euros as start-up capital.
Tony Bloom’s Strategic Investment and the Rise of Data‑Driven Decision Making
After this financial consolidation and the restart in 2014, the club continued to operate successfully both financially and athletically. The club’s collaboration with Jamestown Analytics, among others, helped. Jamestown Analytics is a company owned by Tony Bloom. He made a name for himself with successful sports betting, among other things, and founded the data company Opta, which is very well known in football. He is also the majority shareholder of Brighton & Hove Albion and Union St. Gilloise. In 2017, Jamestown Analytics was founded, another company that advises clubs on the recruitment of players and coaches based on its good data and algorithms. Tony Bloom chooses these clubs independently and only accepts a very select group of clubs. Currently there are only 10 clubs. This includes the clubs controlled by Tony Bloom. Tony Bloom also likes to participate in the associations that Jamestown Analytics advises by purchasing shares. Among others at Melbourne Victory, but also at Heart of Midlothian.
If you want to understand how analytics, Expected Goals (xG) and modern data models influence recruitment and performance — the same principles used by Jamestown Analytics — xGenius by James Tippett is one of the most insightful books available. It breaks down how clubs gain competitive advantages through smarter decision‑making.
In 2025, Tony Bloom bought 29% of Hearts for €11.4 million. Now, of course, one might think that this would be unthinkable for the club due to the bad experiences with Vladimir Romanov. But the club has learned from the experiences and made assumptions to prevent this. First, Tony Bloom, an investor who is familiar with football, was chosen and has already had good experiences with the club through his company Jamestown Analytics. In addition, although the club has given up 29% shares, it has not given up any voting shares of the 75.5% of fan-owned shares. This is a system similar to the 50+1 rule in the Bundesliga, which stipulates that 50% plus one additional vote must lie with the parent club (a detailed explanation can be found here). This clearly shows that Tony Bloom’s investment is purely financial and comes from a high level of trust in the work of the club and its agency Jamestown Analytics. It also distinguishes it from Tony Bloom’s Multi Club Ownership System. A detailed explanation of Multi Club Ownership can be found here. Hearts will not become part of Tony Bloom’s system; instead, a Bloom’s shares will become more of a bet on the club’s success, which has already paid off this season with a second-place finish in the Scottish league.
The reason why Hearts has also entered into a share acquisition agreement with Tony Bloom after years of working with Jamestown Analytics is due to the club’s ongoing rising costs. In its balance sheet for the 2024/25 season, the club reports an increase of 21% of sales to 27.8 million euros. Despite this strong increase on the sales side, the club has a loss of approximately 500,000€. While this loss has little impact, it should not be forgotten that despite a 21% increase on the revenue side, a loss was still achieved. In addition, the club’s debt rose from 4 million euros to 6 million euros. Here, Tony Bloom’s investment with additional capital helps ensure that players do not have to rely on player sales to finance operational business or service debts. This is essential for a club that wants to buy players as cheaply as possible and sell them as expensively as possible in order to practice this successfully. Without existing capital, such so-called training clubs are often forced to sell players at low prices or not keep them until their development is completed and thus also not receive the full sum. In conclusion, Hearts remains a fan-led majority club and sporting and financial developments show that this is the right way to operate successfully in Scottish football.
